YOU CAN EDIT THIS PAGE! Just click any blue "Edit" link and start writing!

Wikitravel:Why Wikitravel isn't GFDL

From Wikitravel
Revision as of 07:03, 25 September 2004 by (talk)
Jump to: navigation, search

Some open content Wiki sites use the GNU Free Documentation License for their work. For Wikitravel, this license doesn't meet our goals, so we've chosen a different one instead. This page tries to explain why.

The GFDL was developed to support making Free Content versions of software manuals, textbooks, and other large references. It has some heavy requirements for what you have to distribute with a document under the GFDL. For example, you have to include a copy of the GFDL, a changelog, as well as "transparent" (i.e. source) versions if you distribute over 100 copies.

These requirements aren't really all that onerous for large volumes of text. But for Wikitravel, we really want to have each article redistributable on its own. Wikitravel articles can be as small as 1-2 printed pages. For such small documents, it just doesn't make sense to require people to pass out another 10 pages of legalese text, as well as floppy disks or CDs full of Wiki markup.

Consider these small "publishers" who would distribute stacks of photocopied printouts of Wikitravel articles:

  • Local tourist offices
  • Hotels or guesthouses
  • Helpful travellers
  • Teachers
  • Exchange student programs
  • Wedding or event planners

Burdening these publishers with restrictions meant for software documentation or textbooks would mean that they'd either ignore our license -- a bad precedent to set -- or, more likely, just not use our work.

We make our content Free so we can collaborate on this wiki, but also because we want it to be seen and used. We can't serve travellers with useful information if they can't get to that information in the first place.

A lightweight alternative

The license we've chosen, the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 1.0, is much easier and more lightweight. We think that using the Attribution-ShareAlike 1.0 license (by-sa) meets our goal of having copyleft protection on Wikitravel content, without putting an excessive burden on small publishers. All that needs to be included are copyright notices, author attribution, and the URL of the license; this can be done in a short paragraph at the end of the article.

The big downside of not using the GFDL is that GFDL content -- like Wikipedia articles -- cannot be included in Wikitravel articles. This is a restriction of the GFDL -- you're not allowed to change the license for the content, unless you're the original copyright holder. This is kind of a pain for contributors, but we figured it was better to make it easy for users and distributors to comply with our license.

Creative Commons has plans to issue a new revision of their suite of licenses at some point in the future. Compatibility with other Free licenses is "a top priority", and we can expect that some time after that version change, articles created on Wikitravel can be distributed under the GFDL. (GFDL compatibility was supposed to be part of the 2.0 version change, but didn't make it in.)

If and when the CC licenses become GFDL compatible, other Free Content authors can include Wikitravel content into their work, even though we can't include GFDL work into Wikitravel.

Other options

If not having your contributions under the GFDL is unacceptable to you for some reason, and you can't wait the few months until the new version of the by-sa comes out that would be compatible with the GFDL, there are a couple of different options.

  • You can contact the Free Software Foundation (FSF), authors of the GFDL, and Creative Commons, authors of the by-sa license, and let them know that the fact that their licenses don't mix is causing you difficulty.
  • You can dual license your work under both the by-sa and the GFDL. Note that this makes collaboration between Wikitravellers more difficult, and requires some attention by you to the stipulations of the GFDL.
  • You can choose not to contribute to Wikitravel. We're sorry our goals don't align with yours, but we hope you can make a contribution somewhere else!

化工 重质碳酸钙 铸造碳化钨 泥浆 聚氯乙烯 无氧化二钒 锰盐 咪唑二甲酸 明矾 木素磺酸钙 木质素磺酸钙 钼粉 钨钼镍 钼酸铵 钼酸钡 钼酸钠 钼铁 氨纶助剂 氨水 铵明矾 螯合铁 八钼酸铵 氢氧化钡 无机颜料 白炭黑 白银 白云母粉 百草枯 半胱氨酸 保险粉 颜料 钡镉膏 钡盐 二甲基苯胺 二甲基甲酰胺 二甲基亚砜 二硫化碳 二氯苯胺 二氯吡啶 二氯化铁 二氯甲烷 二氯菊酸甲酯 二氯乙烷 二氯异氰尿酸钠 二钼酸铵 二羟基蒽醌隐色体 二巯基丙磺酸钠 二水氯化钙 二辛酯 二溴海因 二盐基亚磷酸铅 二氧化碲 分散剂 粉煤灰 一水氢氧化钡 速溶硅酸钠 呋喃甲醛 呋喃树脂 氟苯 氟表面活性剂 氟锆酸盐 氟硅酸 氟硅酸铵 氟硅酸钾 氟硅酸钠 氟化铵 氟化钙 氟化锆 氟化铬 氟化工 氟化钾 氟化锂 氟化铝 氟化镁 氟化钠 氟化镍 氟化氢 氟化氢铵 氟化铷 氟化铯 磷酸二钠 磷酸二氢铵 磷酸二氢钙 磷酸二氢钾 磷酸二氢铝 磷酸二氢钠 氯化铵 氯化钯 氯化钡 氯化苯 氯化苄 氯化胆碱 氯化钙 氯化镉 氯化铬 氯化汞 氯化钴 氯化钾 氯化聚丙烯 氯化聚乙烯 氯化镧 氯化磷酸三钠 氯化铝 氯化镁 氯化锰 氯化钠 氯化钕 氯化镨 氯化氢 磷化液 磷矿粉 磷矿石 磷酸 磷酸二铵 氯化铷 氯化铯 氯化石蜡 氯化铈 氯化锶 氯化橡胶 氯化锌 氯化锌铵 氯化亚铁 氯化亚铁丙酰氯 氯化亚铜 氯化亚锡 氯化铟 氯磺化聚乙烯 氯磺酸 氯甲醚 氯碱 氯磷 氯水杨醛 氯酸钠 氯酸盐 氯酸盐 氯乙酸 洛克沙生 马日夫盐 吗啉 芒硝 芒硝碱 美耐皿 镁锭 蒙脱石干燥剂 锰锭 纳米 纳米乳液 纳米二氧化硅 纳米二氧化钛 纳米活性碳酸钙 纳米氧化锆 纳米氧化铁 氖气 耐火材料粘结剂 萘甲醚 萘乙酮 尼泊金乙酯 尿素 镍盐 柠檬黄 柠檬酸钙 柠檬酸盐 农药 钕铁硼磁体 偶氮二异庚腈 泡花碱 硼酐 硼硅酸铅 硼氢化钾 硼氢化钠 硼砂 硼酸 硼酸锌 膨润土 膨胀蛭石 砒霜 片钙 片碱 偏钒酸铵 偏硅酸钠 偏硼酸钡 偏锑酸钠 漂粉精 葡萄糖酸钠 硅酸盐水泥 普通硫化碱 硫酸亚铁 七钼酸铵 七水硫酸镁 气刨炭棒 铅锭 铅钙合金 铅铬黄 羟基硅油 氢氟酸 氢化钙 氢化锂 氢化铝锂 氢化钠 氢气 氢溴酸 氢氧化钡 氢氧化钙 氢氧化铬 氢氧化铝 氢氧化镍 氢氧化锶 氢氧化锌 氢氧化铟 轻质碳酸 轻质碳酸钙 轻质氧化镁 氰化锌 氰化亚铜 氰化银 氰化银钾 氰基乙醚 氰基乙酯 氰尿酸 钨酸铅 氰亚金酸钾 氰乙酸乙酯 曲酸 全氟辛基磺酰氟 溶解乙炔 熔磷 鞣铬剂 肉碱 乳化剂 乳化碳酸钙 乳酸 三醋酸甘油酯 三丁基氯化锡 三氟化氮 三氟化硼 三氟化锑 三甲苯 塑料编织 塑料编织袋 塑料薄膜袋 莹石粉 硝酸钕 酸式磷酸锰 羧甲基纤维素钠 钛白粉 钛酸钡 钛酸锶 钛酸盐 酞菁蓝 脱氧剂 烷基苯磺酸 微粒三氧化二锑 维生素C 维生素E 稳定氧化锆 乌洛托品 钨钼 钨酸 钨酸钠 钨矿 无尘氧化锑 红矾钠 无汞碱锰电池 无机氟 无机凝胶 无水氟化氢 无水硫化钠 无水硫酸镁 无水硫酸钠 无水氯化钙 无水氯化铁 无水芒硝 无水硼砂 无水三氯化铝 无水四氯化锡 无水亚硫酸钠

门禁 监控 发电机 门禁 门禁 门禁 门禁 监控 监控 监控 监控 监控 监控 监控 虚拟主机 asp虚拟主机 php虚拟主机 unix虚拟主机 windows虚拟主机 纯空间虚拟主机 虚拟主机 虚拟主机 虚拟主机 虚拟主机 空压机 压缩机 消毒剂 化工泵 二氧化氯 网址大全 网址大全 网址大全 网址大全 网址大全 网址大全 网址大全 网址大全 网址大全 网址大全 网址大全 网址大全 网址大全 网址大全 网址大全 网址大全 网址大全 网址大全 网址大全 网址大全 线号机 线号机 打号机 gemstone globe gemstone globe gemstone globe gemstone globe gemstone globe Fireworks Fireworks Fireworks Fireworks Fireworks Fireworks Fireworks Fireworks Fireworks 装修 团购 装修 装修 装修 装修 装修 装修 团购 压缩机 空压机 空压机 空压机 空压机 压缩机 压缩机 压缩机 压缩机 压缩机 发电机 发电机 发电机 发电机 发电机 发电机 发电机 发电机 发电机 发电机 减速机 离心机 化妆品 化妆品 化妆品 化妆品 化妆品 战略咨询 战略咨询 战略咨询 战略咨询 战略咨询 战略咨询 战略咨询 战略咨询 数据恢复