YOU CAN EDIT THIS PAGE! Just click any blue "Edit" link and start writing!

Changes

Jump to: navigation, search

Talk:Scandinavia

91 bytes added, 23:43, 5 February 2005
redirect to Northern Europe
: No. I disagree. [[Scandinavia]], [[Nordic countries]], [[Nordic Europe]], and [[Northern Europe]] are different regions. Although they overlap, they are not entirely the same. Only redirect IDENTICAL articles. '''Scandinavia''' is quite clearly defined and if you are redirecting this to [[Northern Europe]] you then cannot redirect [[Nordic countries]] or [[Nordic Europe]] to the same place. Certainly [[Nordic Europe]] could redirect to [[Nordic countries]], but not the other way as [[Greenland]] is not in Europe. Having multiple overlaping regions helps the traveler define what places are of interest. -- [[User:Huttite|Huttite]] 18:18, 5 Feb 2005 (EST)
:: You have larger experience that I, but I found having '''four''' different articles on '''five''' countries very confusing. In my opinion it's better to have one good article witch which cover all variations, subjects (and terminology) in one place, than spread among places.
:: Moreover, if you look at histories of these four articles, you can see that all of them shared same text content (in a bit different forms). This is confusing, chaotic and redundant (should traveller print all four articles?). -- [[User:JanSlupski|JanSlupski]]
 
:::[[Nordic Europe]] = [[Northern Europe]] [[User:Wojsyl|Wojsyl]] 18:39, 5 Feb 2005 (EST)
553
edits

Navigation menu