Help Wikitravel grow by contributing to an article! Learn how.
New users, please see Help or go to the Pub to ask questions.

Difference between revisions of "Wikitravel:Star nominations/Slush pile"

From Wikitravel
Jump to: navigation, search
 
(Slush pile Yogyakarta)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
This is the '''slush pile''' for [[Wikitravel:Star nominations]] -- articles that were not agreed to be of Star [[Wikitravel:Article status|status]] yet. Articles in the slush pile can be renominated if the criticisms from the previous nomination are addressed.
 
This is the '''slush pile''' for [[Wikitravel:Star nominations]] -- articles that were not agreed to be of Star [[Wikitravel:Article status|status]] yet. Articles in the slush pile can be renominated if the criticisms from the previous nomination are addressed.
  
===[[Scuba diving]]===
+
==[[Scuba diving]]==
  
 
Pretty comprehensive overall coverage of the activity from the point of view of an interested traveller considering learning to dive and beginning divers thinking of organising a dive holiday (it's probably actually the case that there may be two articles in there: Scuba diving destinations, and Scuba diving overview for travellers -- both of which examples show that I should not be naming articles!). [[User:Hypatia|Hypatia]] 00:49, 31 May 2006 (EDT)
 
Pretty comprehensive overall coverage of the activity from the point of view of an interested traveller considering learning to dive and beginning divers thinking of organising a dive holiday (it's probably actually the case that there may be two articles in there: Scuba diving destinations, and Scuba diving overview for travellers -- both of which examples show that I should not be naming articles!). [[User:Hypatia|Hypatia]] 00:49, 31 May 2006 (EDT)
Line 11: Line 11:
  
 
Withdrawn pending addition of a map and improvements to the list of destinations. [[User:Hypatia|Hypatia]] 20:28, 31 July 2006 (EDT)
 
Withdrawn pending addition of a map and improvements to the list of destinations. [[User:Hypatia|Hypatia]] 20:28, 31 July 2006 (EDT)
 +
 +
==[[Yogyakarta]]==
 +
* It's a Guide, it's got a map and it's DOTM.  Let's make it a Star if it isn't one already. [[User:Jpatokal|Jpatokal]] 04:03, 1 October 2006 (EDT)
 +
 +
* Support- Sounds good. Are there any more things that could be added in the '''Do''' Section? [[User:Felixboy|Felixboy]] 14:11, 3 October 2006 (EDT)
 +
* '''Don't support''' for the following reasons:
 +
#"Do" section is less than stellar for a city of 500,000.
 +
#There isn't a "Stay Safe" section or any information pertaining how to avoid hassles, being a crime victim, or natural disasters.
 +
##Added. It's kinda hard to avoid earthquakes though.
 +
#There isn't a "Cope" section.
 +
##Section added, but it's empty...
 +
#MoS is sketchy in some places. 
 +
#Some listings have little or no contact info (I.e. [[Yogyakarta#Sleep]] there isn't an address or phone number for '''"Monical Hotel"'''.  Also, under [[Yogyakarta#Museum]] we provide absolutely no information about the '''"Museum Batik"'''.  There's simply a link to a Wikipedia article about the painting technique, but nothing about the museum.) -- [[User:Sapphire|Sapphire]] 14:22, 3 October 2006 (EDT)
 +
##Correct name is "Monica Hotel", I dug up a phone number but couldn't find an address.  The Museum Batik is so obscure it's not listed in any of my guidebooks, so I just deleted it. [[User:Jpatokal|Jpatokal]] 23:14, 3 October 2006 (EDT)
 +
* '''Don't Support'''.  It's an  awesome article, but. -- [[User:Cjensen|Colin]] 15:59, 4 November 2006 (EST)
 +
*# Bunches of entries lack addresses or directions.  For example, the Saphir Square mall is listed as "Jalan Solo".  If there is no further address that can be given then I withdraw the complaint.
 +
*# Phone numbers often fail MoS.  Maybe switch to the newfangled listings tag and make it Not Your Problem?
 +
*# No prices on Museums.
 +
*# Is JI an abbrev for Jalan?  For consistency, it'd be nice if only one format is used.
 +
*# Would an address for the train station and bus station be helpful?  Or do we just assume the reader will be going by taxi and the taxi driver knows where they are?
 +
*# Have a mentioned lately that I wish there was a level between guide and star?
 +
*'''Don't support.''' Same reasons as above, especially the lack of things in "Do" and the lack of contacts (and info in some places) for "sleep" listings. I want to see this make it as a star, because its pretty close to being there if all these points are sorted. -- [[User:Tsandell|Tim]] 17:11, 4 November 2006 (EST)
 +
*This thing has been pending for quite a long time.  Have the objections been addressed, or should it be slush-piled for now?  Let's make a decision here.  (I have no strong opinions on this article myself.) -- [[User:Bill-on-the-Hill|Bill-on-the-Hill]] 20:12, 16 November 2006 (EST)
 +
 +
:There were quite a few problems and I believe only partial attempts to address the issues were made.  It needs to be slush-piled.  -- Sapphire

Revision as of 02:29, 17 November 2006

This is the slush pile for Wikitravel:Star nominations -- articles that were not agreed to be of Star status yet. Articles in the slush pile can be renominated if the criticisms from the previous nomination are addressed.

Scuba diving

Pretty comprehensive overall coverage of the activity from the point of view of an interested traveller considering learning to dive and beginning divers thinking of organising a dive holiday (it's probably actually the case that there may be two articles in there: Scuba diving destinations, and Scuba diving overview for travellers -- both of which examples show that I should not be naming articles!). Hypatia 00:49, 31 May 2006 (EDT)

  • 1) A map pinpointing the most popular dive destinations might help out the geopolitically challenged who don't know where, say, Thailand or Malta is. 2) I think you may be right that this is more than one article. There's a lot here, and either splitting it up and editing it down to cover just the most-travel-related aspects would help. - 19:56, 31 May 2006 (EDT)
  • Support. I've never been scuba diving, but I definately could go ahead and start my own scuba diving school with this article. - Andrew Haggard (Sapphire) 09:07, 9 June 2006 (EDT)
  • Support. The article definitely meets the criteria for star article. —The preceding unsigned comment was added by EmbrunOntario (talkcontribs)
  • Oppose. I've been a big contributor to the article and I like it, but I think the index of scuba destinations up front needs a lot more work — it should cover all the biggies and give nutshell summaries. I don't think any splitting is needed at this stage. Jpatokal 09:40, 27 July 2006 (EDT)

Withdrawn pending addition of a map and improvements to the list of destinations. Hypatia 20:28, 31 July 2006 (EDT)

Yogyakarta

  • It's a Guide, it's got a map and it's DOTM. Let's make it a Star if it isn't one already. Jpatokal 04:03, 1 October 2006 (EDT)
  • Support- Sounds good. Are there any more things that could be added in the Do Section? Felixboy 14:11, 3 October 2006 (EDT)
  • Don't support for the following reasons:
  1. "Do" section is less than stellar for a city of 500,000.
  2. There isn't a "Stay Safe" section or any information pertaining how to avoid hassles, being a crime victim, or natural disasters.
    1. Added. It's kinda hard to avoid earthquakes though.
  3. There isn't a "Cope" section.
    1. Section added, but it's empty...
  4. MoS is sketchy in some places.
  5. Some listings have little or no contact info (I.e. Yogyakarta#Sleep there isn't an address or phone number for "Monical Hotel". Also, under Yogyakarta#Museum we provide absolutely no information about the "Museum Batik". There's simply a link to a Wikipedia article about the painting technique, but nothing about the museum.) -- Sapphire 14:22, 3 October 2006 (EDT)
    1. Correct name is "Monica Hotel", I dug up a phone number but couldn't find an address. The Museum Batik is so obscure it's not listed in any of my guidebooks, so I just deleted it. Jpatokal 23:14, 3 October 2006 (EDT)
  • Don't Support. It's an awesome article, but. -- Colin 15:59, 4 November 2006 (EST)
    1. Bunches of entries lack addresses or directions. For example, the Saphir Square mall is listed as "Jalan Solo". If there is no further address that can be given then I withdraw the complaint.
    2. Phone numbers often fail MoS. Maybe switch to the newfangled listings tag and make it Not Your Problem?
    3. No prices on Museums.
    4. Is JI an abbrev for Jalan? For consistency, it'd be nice if only one format is used.
    5. Would an address for the train station and bus station be helpful? Or do we just assume the reader will be going by taxi and the taxi driver knows where they are?
    6. Have a mentioned lately that I wish there was a level between guide and star?
  • Don't support. Same reasons as above, especially the lack of things in "Do" and the lack of contacts (and info in some places) for "sleep" listings. I want to see this make it as a star, because its pretty close to being there if all these points are sorted. -- Tim 17:11, 4 November 2006 (EST)
  • This thing has been pending for quite a long time. Have the objections been addressed, or should it be slush-piled for now? Let's make a decision here. (I have no strong opinions on this article myself.) -- Bill-on-the-Hill 20:12, 16 November 2006 (EST)
There were quite a few problems and I believe only partial attempts to address the issues were made. It needs to be slush-piled. -- Sapphire

Variants

Actions

Destination Docents

In other languages