Want to help improve the guide? Create an account now to get started!

Difference between revisions of "User talk:Epolk"

From Wikitravel
Jump to: navigation, search
(Wallowa Lake, OR)
(constructive contributions)
Line 19: Line 19:
 
:3 - If the content is wrong, correct it.  This is a wiki after all and you know how to edit this wiki as you have edited my talk page.
 
:3 - If the content is wrong, correct it.  This is a wiki after all and you know how to edit this wiki as you have edited my talk page.
 
:[[User:Epolk|Epolk]] 11:55, 11 July 2012 (EDT)
 
:[[User:Epolk|Epolk]] 11:55, 11 July 2012 (EDT)
 +
 +
==Constructive contributions==
 +
 +
Hi Epolk, I notice you have a history very constructive contribution to the WT project in the past.  I hope you are still reading this page, and still interested in this project to create a reliable, up-to-date free travel guide. Wikitravel's community is currently considering migrating to the '''Wikimedia Foundation''', and I'd like to let you know where you can find out more about this proposal. A good overview of the process and reasons for the migration can be found in this [http://wikivoyage.org/general/Migration_FAQ FAQ]. All the best, [[User:Felix505|felix]] 22:40, 19 August 2012 (EDT)

Revision as of 02:44, 20 August 2012

Welcome to wikitravel, thanks for the contributions you made on Las Vegas and Vatican City. If you have any questions feel free to drop some comments on my talk page (aburda) and I'll do my best to help in anyway. Regards, Aburda 07:55, 12 Aug 2005 (EDT)

Hello Epolk. It's great that you are updating numerous pages for American war cemeteries around the world on pages such as Florence, Aachen, and Cambridge_(England). I copyedited your listing for Aachen, but noticed some of the same things coming up in other pages, so perhaps I thought I would let you know so that you can improve the other pages also. Some points:
The Wikitravel external link policy is to not front-link external URLs, but rather have the link after the attraction name. Apart from that, I wikified some of the place names and corrected a couple of typos (Cemetary --> cemetery, idetified --> identified) and got rid of the capitals on cemetery and dead. Keep up the good work. Brendio 15:57, 17 Jan 2006 (EST)

Wallowa Lake, OR

In your blurb on the history of the lake, you state that "the government took back most of its land from the tribe." This is totally inaccurate. The land belonged to the Nez Perce, since it was theirs long before non-Indians arrived in the Northwest, and since the U.S. government acknowledged this in the Treaty of 1855. In that treaty, the Nez Perce reserved, among other areas, the Wallowa Valley for themselves. Therefore, the government didn't take back any land; it wasn't government land to begin with. The U.S. outright took the Wallowas from the Nez Perce. It was essentially theft.

This is an important distinction. We can't learn from the past and our ancestors roles in the past unless we deal with the past honestly. I don't believe you are dishonest; but your blurb is exceedingly careless.

Chris Shelley

A few points on this:
1 - If you are going to post a criticism to someone you should at least take the courtesy of having a registered account so a dialogue can take place.
2 - I didn't create the content for that article, I was simply correcting the grammar and spelling mistakes in the article. If you take the time to research incorrect statements you should also research the history to see who created the content originally. Don't just pick the first person in the history who is registered and lay into them about something they did not do.
Unfortunately, the original creator of the content, much like you, did not register; thus, there is no way to have a civil discourse with the creator about word choices.
3 - If the content is wrong, correct it. This is a wiki after all and you know how to edit this wiki as you have edited my talk page.
Epolk 11:55, 11 July 2012 (EDT)

Constructive contributions

Hi Epolk, I notice you have a history very constructive contribution to the WT project in the past. I hope you are still reading this page, and still interested in this project to create a reliable, up-to-date free travel guide. Wikitravel's community is currently considering migrating to the Wikimedia Foundation, and I'd like to let you know where you can find out more about this proposal. A good overview of the process and reasons for the migration can be found in this FAQ. All the best, felix 22:40, 19 August 2012 (EDT)

Variants

Actions

Destination Docents

In other languages