Thanks for your contributions to Barcelona. As several editors have tried to point out, the Wikitravel:Accommodation listings policy is pretty clear that an apartment rental agency can only be listed when there is a local office that travelers can visit to pick up keys, resolve problems, etc. From the website of the agency your listing it does not appear to meet that criteria and is therefore (unfortunately) inappropriate for a Wikitravel article. If you disagree with this policy please read the rationale for it on Wikitravel talk:Accommodation listings#Proposal and make any suggestions that you feel might improve the guideline. -- Ryan(talk) 03:17, 27 March 2007 (EDT)
The owner or guardian of the accommodation will give you the keys when he shows you into the accommodation. The steps outlining what you should do to arrange to meet the owner/guardian will be explained in the booking confirmation we will send you.
Could you please correct this on your website first before asking us to list your apartment service so that we have obvious confirmation that you have met our guidelines for listing. -- Colin 03:47, 27 March 2007 (EDT)
It looks like Flip666's removal of your listing in Paris seems to have annoyed you to the point of vandalism. Would you like to talk about it? There have always been multiple theories here on external linking, you might well find you have allies if you want to take up the cause. -- Mark 08:46, 27 March 2007 (EDT)
The removal of my listing didn´t make any sense since the other links in Paris are very similar (commercially speaking). So can someone be straight and tell me what the guidelines are for adding a listing?
OK people, I read the rules concerning apartment listings. The listing I was trying to put up meets the last three conditions, but not the first. A legitimate reason for throwing me off the page one could conclude. But concerning the first condition, we do have a 'real world' office with a phone number and a address. The only thing that does not happen is that the actual tourist will come up to our office to pick up the keys. Seems a rather complicated procedure to me. Why make things so hard for a Wikitraveller? Why not go directly to the apartment where the keys will be handed over to the person in question for the time of rental? Can someone explain me the logic behind condition one?
Owners of apartments, condos, and vacation homes sometimes arrange with a rental agency to rent out their place when they aren't using it. In order to list an agency in Wikitravel, it must meet the following conditions:
1. The agency must have a 'real world' office with a phone number and address where the keys will be picked up.
2. Rentals of less than 1 week must be available.
3. The lodgings must not be available to rent directly through the owner
4. Must be in a location where travelers frequently rent cabins/apartments
If you feel that I did something wrong, please talk to us! Vandalism is useless. It is one click for us to revert all your edits. You are editing on the German version, too, so if you like to talk in German you can leave me a message there: de:Benutzer_Diskussion:Flip666. --Flip666writeme! • 08:51, 27 March 2007 (EDT)